SCI期刊主編，分析審稿意見

題目1【某題目的審稿意見】“The title and objective do not agree well. What the manuscript actually presents is not well described in the introduction and in the title. The authors do not express clearly and consistently the aims, objectives and rationale of the study” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：B

A：太泛，無核心信息

B：不能準(zhǔn)確互相反映

C：縮寫/簡寫

D：太普通

題目2【某摘要的審稿意見】“The abstract should be re-written in short form to highlight briefly the state of the problem, research motivation, work objectives and scope ” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：A

A：太長，< 150-250

B：要素不完整

C：要素不準(zhǔn)確

題目3【某引言的審稿意見】“The literature review in the introduction is weak - I would expect better treatment of the literature related specifically to state estimation in a marine environment” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：C

A：太短或長

B：要素不完整

C：深度不夠

D：脫離后文

E：邏輯不清晰

F：語言質(zhì)量低

G：參考文獻(xiàn)舊或不全

題目4【某方法的審稿意見】“By using a double shear test specimen in conjunction with preloaded bolts, radial displacements of the tubes arising from Barlow’s formula are totally neglected. The radial stiffness of the connection is wrongly considered and mostly overestimated if bolts are used.” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：A

A：方法不嚴(yán)謹(jǐn)

B：方法描述不充分

C：樣本不具代表性

D：數(shù)據(jù)分析不合理

E：沒有控制樣本／條件

F：原型不具代表性

題目5【某結(jié)果的審稿意見】“This structure strengthen the impression that this section is a bulleted list of results rather than a reasoned presentation of your findings. I would suggest to address this issue.” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：D

A：冗余，無創(chuàng)新

B：圖表太多

C：圖形質(zhì)量太差

D：羅列結(jié)果，邏輯性差

E：結(jié)果內(nèi)容缺失、反常

題目6【某討論的審稿意見】“In general, during the discussion of test results, the authors are suggested to state more clearly whether the rebars are transverse reinforcement or longitudinal reinforcement. Two types of reinforcement may contribute to the column in different ways.” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：C

A：結(jié)構(gòu)不合理，與結(jié)果不密切

B：討論不完整

C：討論不深入，不具體

D：缺乏文獻(xiàn)引用

題目7【某結(jié)論的審稿意見】“Are authors sure that the considered building can give general information on the studied phenomena? The conclusions may be valid only for this case.” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：F

A：不準(zhǔn)確或低價(jià)值

B：說服力弱，無數(shù)據(jù)支撐

C：邏輯不夠，閱讀不順暢

D：描述概括過多，下結(jié)論過少

E：無價(jià)值分析或局限性分析

F：適用范圍過大

題目8【某參考文獻(xiàn)的審稿意見】“I go through the paper, and found that there are 14 refs. and 10 of them are from China. We may think the paper to be regional and may not attract international researchers.” 請(qǐng)選出最匹配的選項(xiàng)：

正確答案：B

A：文獻(xiàn)太舊

B：文獻(xiàn)不夠國際化分布

C：有無法獲取或下載的文獻(xiàn)

D：用中文撰寫的文獻(xiàn)

E：格式不符合期刊要求

F：文獻(xiàn)數(shù)量太少或太多